[AMENDED] Proposed AIW - Solidarity with Palestinians

The statement below is from the Southwest Asian & North African Caucus of Diverse Revolutionary UU Multicultural Ministries (SWANA DRUUMM Caucus). You can find it on the AIW UU Solidarity with Palestine website.

We are Unitarian Universalists of Southwest Asian & North African, or SWANA, descent. We use this terminology in the place of “Arab” or “Middle Eastern” to better represent the diversity of our identities and to move away from the colonialist language that has been put upon us.

As the DRUUMM SWANA caucus, we not only support this Action of Immediate Witness, but implore our fellow Unitarian Universalists to adopt it in solidarity and shared struggle with our lives.

We are a small but steadfast caucus. You may have never even heard of us until this very moment. There is a reason for that.

For decades, Palestinian hearts and pain have been back-burnered by our association and its members. Time and time again, we, and especially our Palestinian members, have witnessed and experienced the discomfort of other members of our faith privileged above our own survival. We have listened as concerns about the departure of some members of our congregations have been treated as more valuable than the existence of our own bodies and lives. We have watched our ancestral lands and homelands be bombed and decimated by a government funded by our own tax dollars, and when we turn to our Unitarian Universalist faith for support in protecting our lives, we receive pushback that to do so will cause people to leave.

People have already left. We have already left. In the decades since the Israeli occupation and apartheid of Palestine began, our faith tradition has repeatedly failed and excluded us.

When we ask for our faith’s communities and members to listen to and support our needs, we are met with a consistent ignorance in tone from our fellow Unitarian Universalists. At times, it is even an infantilization of our being, marred in centuries long Orientalism and the disregard of principled UU values. We have witnessed the complete and utter disregard of the 1st Principle and 4th Principles, the abandonment of the values of equity & transformation, when we bring up even the possibility of discussing Palestinian life, sovereignty, self-determination, and inherent worth. It has been oppressively solidified into our collective psyche that our principles and values only apply under specific circumstances, to a selective group of people. Time and time again, we have been reminded of our “inferiority” through the abnegation of the indigenous rights of Palestinians.

The cause of Palestine is at the very heart of what it means to be SWANA. They are the last vestige of a colonial struggle that has existed for 532 years among our peoples. The resilience of Palestinians serves as an inspiration in resisting the more insidious forms of neo-colonialism and imperialism ongoing and embedded in our home countries.

For us, Palestine has far reaching cultural significance. For thousands of years, Palestine has been a unique multicultural, multiethnic, and multireligious regional hub. Well before the Abrahamic faiths emerged on our planet, Palestine connected polytheistic traditions throughout the Mediterranean. Ancient empires which once ruled our lands spoke of this place. Ancient Egyptians, Assyrians, Greeks, and Romans documented Palestine in their encyclopedias, letters, chronicles, on their coinage, and in their ‘world maps.’ Palestine became the first instance of cosmopolitanism, and as such, the country served as a catalyst for what it means to be of SWANA descent.

To come from these places is to be a part of a multicultural and dynamic space unlike any other. Palestine is central to the local psyche, collective historical memories, and cultural intricacies of those of us SWANA descent.

Growing up, the children of Southwest Asia and North Africa are told stories of our ancient roots. The connections to the land and its people are embedded into our languages, identities, pride, and ultimately our very being. As a result we reject the myth-narratives which have been propped up by colonial empires for hundreds of years.

We reject the “divide and conquer” strategies present in the colonial persuasions. There is no binary between Jew or Arab, Palestinian or Israeli. There is no “us vs. them” in our view. This binary not only serves as a blatant disregard of other ethnic, racial, and ethno-religious groups in Palestine — such as Afro-Palestinians, Armenians, Druze, Samaritans, Ethiopian Jews, and Naqab Bedouin peoples — but also serves as a tool for the perpetrators of colonialism to stir the flames of division. No healing can occur if we continue to act as though there is an innate impasse to coexistence. For thousands of years, we coexisted, and it can be done for thousands of more years.

Palestinians live under a brutal military occupation. Novel armaments, tools of torture, and methods of psychological warfare are used on everyday Palestinians. They are the ‘guinea pigs’ for the West and dictatorial regime around the world. In the innovations of our global military industrial complex, Palestinian bodies are brutalized in the same way Black bodies are brutalized. When the murder of George Floyd was plastered in our memories, those of SWANA descent instantly drew connections to our years of watching Israeli soldiers placing their knees on the necks of adolescent Palestinians. When we watched the St. Louis Police Department, after the killing of Michael Brown, lay siege upon Ferguson — we were immediately stunned by the identical tactics, militarized vehicles, and chemical warfare techniques that were used. Before the Atlanta Police Department (APD) killed 92-year old Kathyrn Johnson, they had just come from a joint training program with Israeli soldiers. For years, the Georgia International Law Enforcement Exchange program has trained, militarized, and emboldened the APD. And now through the APD building of “Cop City” we see that they are creating a mass surveillance network modeled after Israel. Time and time again, we watch Atlanta police chiefs draw comparisons to “struggles for justice” in Israel and Georgia. The APD has made it apparent to the public that they see Tel Aviv and Atlanta as “sister cities.” It was just a decade ago that the New York Police Department admitted to emulating their “Demographics Unit” (which spied on Muslim and Arab citizens), after Israel’s occupation tactics in the West Bank. Now dozens of “Cop City’s” are being erected around the United States, and thousands of officers are being trained by the Israeli military. The generation of an overt police-state, akin to Israel, is apparent to us. History is repeating itself, because we did not act on these revelations quick enough. Our communities did have the tools to join together in solidarity. Now that is changing. Across the United States, the protest chant “APD, KKK, IDF: they’re all the same” is being popularized. Across the West Bank, the face of George Floyd has been painted on the same concrete walls which imprison Palestinians in their own home. It is in these intersections of justice, in which we recognize that freedom for everyone cannot occur without the freedom of the Palestinian people.

This intersectionality in the recognition of the basic humanity of all peoples is far-reaching. When we witness Indigenous struggles for self-determination in the Amazon jungle, we are inspired by their dedication. When we watch U.S. politicians and pundits call for the “eradication of transgenderism,” we are disgusted by their hatred. When we witness the ethnic cleansing of Darfuri peoples in Sudan, we are horrified by the cruelty. When we watch the decades long genocide in the Congo, being enabled by imperial entities, we are angered by their sheer disregard for human life.

The struggles of Palestinians encompasses the struggles of all peoples who’ve been the victims of colonialism, imperialism, slavery, white supremacy, capitalist greed, and ideological fascism.

We ask our faith community to vote in support of this AIW as one small move towards creating a new global narrative. One that says imperialism is not part of our languages of love and liberation. One that refuses to call resistance to white supremacy and colonialism evil. One that refuses to stay silent in the face of genocide. One that says the potential of each human is worth feeding, and that all people deserve a world that affirms their dignity. A narrative rooted in the multiplicity of Unitarian Universalism as a model to save the world.

20 Likes

I went back and read what you said:

“The stories about raped & brutally slaughtered women, about beheaded babies & other shocking atrocities–these were part of a disinformation campaign that (interestingly) Netanyahu had ready to go on Oct. 7th”

Is there some mistake, or did you really say that? Was it taken out of context?

1 Like

I am so deeply grateful for this courageous, prophetic call to Unitarian Universalists. Thank you to the SWANA Caucus for crafting this statement and entrusting it here to the wider community.

8 Likes

this is such a profound and powerful statement…

6 Likes

All respect to the members of the SWANA DRUUMM caucus for modeling how to widen the circle of UU concern to include Palestinians and others from the SWANA region without exception! And for naming important truths about the intersections of imperialism, colonialism, militarism, and militarized policing.

9 Likes

Thank you so much for this profound and powerful statement. :purple_heart:

7 Likes

Again, what I was pointing out is that the Netanyahu claims that Hamas beheaded babies & brutally slaughtered women on Oct. 7th have been investigated and discovered to be unfounded. No way am I denying that there was in fact a Hamas attack, (nor that it was a war crime).

If you’re interested in knowing about the war crimes that are being committed every day now, I refer you to the 6/19/24 report on this to the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva: Israel’s actions in Gaza ‘intentional attack on civilians’: UN inquiry | Israel-Palestine conflict News | Al Jazeera

4 Likes

No one said that there aren’t other colonialist aggressions going on all over the world, perpetrated by the most powerful countries. Here though we’re talking about the colonialist apartheid in Israel/Palestine that our own government is collaborating in and funding with our tax dollars.

As a citizen of a supposedly democratic country, I feel it’s my moral duty to oppose this and do what I can to save the Palestinians from the genocidal intentions Netanyahu & his extreme right confreres have openly declared over & over again in one form or another. Even his own military is now bowing out of what they see as an impossible military objective: Israeli military spokesman’s Hamas defeat remarks widen rift with Netanyahu | Israel-Palestine conflict News | Al Jazeera .

Netanyahu & his gang are the ones who’re destroying Israel. Despite news censorship in Israel, the Israelis have awakened to this via witnessing how he’s sacrificing the hostages to pursue his own personal & political goals. They’re in the streets calling him out on this and clamoring for him to be thrown out of office, with the Netanyahu state police force moving in on them as if they were outside agitators, rough them up (including many elderly fathers & mothers of hostages), and arresting the ones who’re most troublesome: Arrests and injuries in Israeli antigovernment protests | Israel-Palestine conflict News | Al Jazeera .

5 Likes

This takes the breath out of me–talk about speaking truth to power!

Thank you so much for laying it all out there so movingly and so clearly.

I join my prayers to yours that the Solidarity with Palestinians AIW be adopted. By a wide margin.

I feel the UU is up to this challenge but it does involve complexities & risks. We’re being put to the test about what our core values really are when faced with the possibility of struggle, loss, and/or psychic injury if we commit ourselves to put those those values into action in our church community and, beyond that, in our world.

6 Likes

To Antony and everyone else who has suggested changes to the wording of the AIW:

That is not an option. Go to the Bylaws

https://www.uua.org/files/2023-05/uua_bylaws_05222023.pdf

and search on “actions of immediate witness.” They come before the General Assembly and the delegates can vote yes or no.

So the question is: will you support this AIW as written? Or do you want it to be voted down? Them’s the choices.

There are things I would change about it, and I was asked my thoughts by the authors so I sent them along while it was still in formation. Now I can decide whether to vote for it. And there is absolutely no question in my mind that I want it to be approved, so I have endorsed it, will speak for it tomorrow, and will vote for it enthusiastically as well.

7 Likes

I completely agree that Israel’s actions are horrific, violate international law, and should be ceased immediately. I also believe that we should be condemning Hamas’ actions for the same reasons. Having an amendment to support Palestinians without clearly condemning Hamas shows tacit support for that terrorist organization. I cannot understand why the authors of this AIW, when faced with that issue, did not change the text. Decrying the events of Oct 7 is not enough.

1 Like

What do you mean, it is explicitly on the side of Hamas? It sounds like you do not know what the word “explicitly” means.

Furthermore, it is not even implicitly on the side of Hamas.

Your suggestion that anyone who considers Netanyahu a cynical schemer is like a Holocaust denier is absurd–do you want a list of 20 of his cynical schemes, or will 5 do?–and the suggestion that the only motivation is anti-Semitism or Jew-hatred is a very, very tired ploy. I’ve been a left-wing Jew all my life, critical of Israeli governments most of that time, and a Zionist for a lot of it, and every single time I criticized anything done by Israel, there was someone somewhere (someone Jewish, I mean) to tell me that that was self-hatred.

What an offensive load of hooey.

Jewish ethics had a profound effect on me growing up and still do, many years after becoming a UU. There is nothing in them that excuses expelling someone from their home so that you can take it over, even if you are literally, at that very moment, running for your life and seeking shelter. On the contrary, that would be a terrible crime and breach of halakhah (Jewish law).

The dangers that drove Jews to seek refuge in the homeland of our long-ago ancestors–pogroms and persecutions in the 19th and early 20th century, then the Holocaust–absolutely do mean that “racist European settler colonialism” doesn’t justly or fully portray the reasons that a Jewish state was established in Palestine. But racism, European supremacy, and white supremacy were in the mix. And of course, in the past few decades, the settler movement has been explicitly settler-colonialist.

None of this means that the modern state of Israel should cease to exist. Most, if not all, nations were forged in part by violence, theft and injustice, including our own. Most of the people now living in Israel inherited the situation, and are not to blame any more than I am to blame for the violence against the Ohlone that made it possible, several generations later, for me to buy a house on their land here in San Francisco and call it mine. I don’t owe it to the Ohlone to hand over my deed. But I do owe them something: to work for, vote for, advocate for their self-determination. Don’t you think so?

Don’t you think that the Palestinians have a right to self-determination?

Neither Israel nor the United States has ever made Palestinians a credible offer of statehood or self-determination. The UN did not make such an offer in 1947–instead, it offered the Jewish one-third of the population 56% of the land, while proposing to cram the two-thirds of the people who were Palestinian into 42% of the land. Would you consider that a just offer today?

It is past time that Palestinians be given self-determination and a state of their own, as messy and difficult as it will be to get there. And as a US citizen, a person of faith, and a person whose morality is deeply rooted in and sustained by Judaism, I have an obligation to help move us in that direction. This AIW states that intent.

8 Likes

The fact that anti-Semitism exists does not mean it is anti-Semitic to hold Israel to international standards.

Israel has systematically bombed and invaded the Gaza Strip, forcing people into the southern tip, and then bombing and invading the southern tip. It has killed tens of thousands of Gazans, the vast majority of whom were civilians and probably half of whom were children (since about half the people in Gaza were children). This is completely disproportionate to the damage inflicted upon Israel and Israelis in the horrific attacks of October 7, and it is a deliberate act of collective punishment.

None of this is new or surprising. The IDF has long practiced, and explicitly proclaimed, a policy of collective punishment and drastically disproportionate response.

It is very hard to fight an enemy like Hamas, yes. Israel has a right to defend itself against such an enemy, yes. And it is still unconscionable and inexcusable to call collective punishment and drastically disproportionate response “self-defense.”

I am struck by how many people, including dearly beloved UUs right here in this space, defend Israel for waging this kind of war who protest vociferously (and rightly) when the United States wages this kind of war.

8 Likes

I’m pleased to see this point “protect the freedom and safety of solidarity activists by supporting protests and opposing legislation and policies that restrict First Amendment rights”. Here in New Jersey our state legislature is posed to adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism. This spring 2 high school students were suspended as they attempted to organize a peaceful walk out that would have called for support for basic human rights, the county commissioners threatened to withhold federal funding to the school district. As UUs we need to certainly show solidarity with the Palestinians and we need to advocate for healing and peace, as we do!
With that, thank you to those who worked on this Action of Witness. I hope it passes.

1 Like

I believe you are mistaken. In the talk, Prof. Khalidi squarely puts the “blame” for the Iraq war on President George W. Bush, Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney. NO WHERE in the talk does he even mention Miami or Long Island. Knowing Prof. Khalidi’s scholarship, having read several of his books and heard him speak, what you are asserting is not something he would say. I can only conclude that you are thinking of a talk given by someone else.

2 Likes

By way of conclusion today, I want to say I’m glad we can have this dialogue re the Solidarity with Palestinians AIW. Obviously, there’s a great deal involved and a great deal at stake. May our better angels guide us.

Toward that end, here’re some online sources of news & analysis I find trustworthy and journalistically up to snuff re doing their homework and providing context for what’s happening, which makes it at least reasonably possible to figure out WHY it’s happening (google for their websites and/or YouTube videos):

–Democracy Now
– Chris Hedges
–Al Jazeera
–The Grayzone
–Novara Media

Two prominent Jewish scholars who provide in-depth analysis & commentary:

*ILAN PAPPE, Israeli historian, political scientist, and former politician: Professor at University of Exeter College of Social Sciences & International Studies in UK, Director of the university’s European Centre for Palestine Studies, and Co-director of the Exeter Centre for Ethno-Political Studies. Author of many books on Israel/Palestine. (Pappé was also a board member of the Israeli political party, Hasash and was a candidate in the 1996 & 1999 Israeli legislative elections.)

*NORMAN FINKLESTEIN, U.S. Professor of Political Science from NYC whose primary fields of research are the Holocaust and Israeli-Palestine; now retired, has held academic positions in a number of universities and published a number of books.

Finally, in case you’re interested in a few of the significant developments on the Israel-Palestine & UN fronts:

UN Human Rights Council report:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gyNZ-CmjUaw OR https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IF3Cy3zR4Qs

Israel’s actions in Gaza ‘intentional attack on civilians’: UN inquiry | Israel-Palestine conflict News | Al Jazeera

Israeli military leader pronounces Netanyahu’s war mission impossible to achieve:

Israeli military spokesman’s Hamas defeat remarks widen rift with Netanyahu | Israel-Palestine conflict News | Al Jazeera

Israeli uprising against Netanyahu in Jerusalem:

Arrests and injuries in Israeli antigovernment protests | Israel-Palestine conflict News | Al Jazeera

Manana,
Jerilyn

3 Likes

I just realized that, although the video was of a public meeting, the 2 teachers involved in the situation might not want such wide publicity, so I deleted my post from an hour ago.

Just listen to his Ware lecture. He said it. I was there and rewatch it every year.

2 Likes

Warning this movie has video and discussion of sexual violence. This is about Oct 7th atrocities. We cannot condemn Hamas for this?

2 Likes

The claims in this video have been found to be significantly lacking evidence when investigated by people further from the center. Here is a detailed debunking of this story:

Also, can it be considered that even if these stories were true, the answer is not to genocide and ethnically cleanse an entire people?

Also important to consider is that these false claims distract from a long history of credible, well documented physical, mental and sexual torture of Palestinian’s abducted and perpetrated by Israeli military.

One more note, these false claims pull from dehumanizing white supremacist narratives of brown skinned savage sexual predators and use of them is extremely damaging.

3 Likes